Thursday, June 6, 2013

Book Review: Lost Men by Rajorshi Chakraborti

Title: Lost Men
Author: Rajorshi Chakraborti
Publisher: Hachette India
Pages: 264
Price: Rs 350
Genre: Literary Fiction / Short stories
Rating: 7/10
Format: Paperback

It is a collection of 9 short stories and a novella. It is not a page-turner and is not meant to be. There is no room for frivolity, it demands absolute attention from the reader or you risk missing some finer nuances. I must confess there were times when I re-read certain parts.

‘Lost Men’ is not for everyone. There are no conclusive endings to most of the stories in the book; the reader is left to draw his own conclusions. The book is replete with dark humour, with ordinary circumstances spiraling into situations beyond control. ‘Lost Men’ has its moments when you don’t regret reading it.

The first story Knock Knock itself provides a glimpse of what to expect. A bank employee pursuing a regular couple for formalities looks like a believable, normal situation, which most of us have gone through; but how the story progresses, sets pace and spirals into an abrupt ending, makes you want more of it; but then you are left to yourself to comprehend what might have been of the situation.

The Last Time I Tried To Leave Home is another quirky story, which also can happen to anybody. A person is out to catch an international flight and finds a lot of time on hand to spare. He decides to take a little detour to pass some time, and then one thing leads to another. I found this story, in spite of the narrator’s situation, quite amusing. Half An Hour is another similar story, though the similarity is limited to how an ordinary situation leads to relatable yet bizarre circumstances.

The Good Boy is a personal favourite. It starts with the memory of a friend who committed suicide twenty years ago in strange circumstances. It is about reaching out to close the open chapters of the past.  

The Third Beside Us is another weird story, and so is A Good Dry-Cleaner Is Worth A Story.

Lost Men is about a man trying to deal with the death of his wife. He keeps moving to different places, meeting different along the way. He is always suspicious of what people tell him, looking for motives behind them. Recalling memories of yearning for his wife in the past, he writes, “Until now, during any separation, each night apart had also brought us one day closer to the moment of our reunion; I would go to bed thinking I’d served out another day of my sentence. Now the sentence had no limits; you we're never brought any closer to the day of your release. You just kept falling further away.”

City Lights is about a chance meeting with the childhood family doctor that evokes nostalgia, and also how the narrator finds himself in a place which looks familiar only from the descriptions in a friend’s letter from many years ago.

What I enjoyed most were Viju’s Version and the novella, Down to Experience. Viju’s Version is about a boy / man whose best intentions are marred by his excessively bad luck. A bright, promising school boy has to go through public humiliation in the wake of his innocent though wanton actions which brings much infamy to his school. He isn't let alone even when he grows up. His nature of work leads him to Maoists. The story also has his school teacher’s version, who he runs into a few times during the course of the story, and how she perceives him.   

Down to Experience is a completely different story in terms of background, people and context. It takes a while to get into the world of Ivan, who is central to the story. The story is set in the late 1940s, about a group of people caught in the conflict of different ideologies, issues of trust among themselves, of what they are and what they seem to be, and whether they are writing their own destiny or just playing in the hands of higher powers.    

Personally, I don’t like short stories. I prefer bigger books, the fatter the better. I like to know the characters intimately and spend time with them. This book opened a different kind of writing that was more accommodating of the reader.

Read it if you like literary fiction and fancy unconventional narrative. Here’s an author interview to give you more perspective on the book.    

Review Book courtesy: Hachette India
Image source: Hachette India


  1. Hmmm so u managed to finish it!!! I need to dig it out!! As I said, I didn't dislike the portions I had read, found it quirky but it is difficult to finish the book! Short stories i no like!

  2. Yes I did :-) I am also not a short story person. But if I start a book, I have to finish it unless it is unbearable. I quite liked some of the stories. Have you read 'Viju's Version'? Quite good. Refreshing storytelling. I also liked 'Down to Experience', 'The Good Boy' andd 'The Last Time...'. The stories are full of dark humour, and in retrospect, you will discover a lot of things.

    1. I would really like to know your views when you are done. Review or otherwise. It is certainly a different kind of writing, not mainstream but likeable.

  3. I agree it's not every body's cup of tea but so are most of lit fiction and short stories unlike popular fiction which tends to have mass appeal. Loved the collection with exception of a couple of stories. The dark humour does seem to be first thing that strikes the reader!

    1. I completely agree that is why I wanted to give a clear picture of what to expect. You would agree that most books have a set of readers. It has to be pitched correctly.

  4. Hi,
    I'm reaching out to you on behalf of Scooze. We're a New Delhi based startup and are building an online community where people come together to help each other across various areas such as Books, Food & Nightlife, Gadgets, Parenting, Education, etc. At Scooze, our goal is to make it easy for anybody who's looking for help to connect with and get recommendations from a 'gang' of the right peers and experts. 
    I'd love to invite you to join the Books Gang on Scooze. A lot of people can benefit immensely from your knowledge and recommendations. We'd be overjoyed if you could try out Scooze and 'join the gang' at
    Also, we'd also love to showcase you on Scooze and our Facebook Page as one of the esteemed expert members of the Books Gang on Scooze. Do let me know if you think this is okay. Our Facebook Page is
    I look forward to your response.
    Thank you.
    Team Scooze